Kaizer Chiefs Legend Shane McGregor Reveals Why He Was Never Allowed to Take Penalties

In an era defined by flair, passion, and trophies, Shane McGregor carved his name into Kaizer Chiefs folklore as one of the most lethal strikers to ever wear the gold and black. Yet, despite his reputation as a goal machine during the 1980s and early 1990s, the former Glamour Boys forward has revealed a surprising truth — he was never permitted to take penalties during regular matches.

McGregor, who formed a formidable attacking partnership with Fani Madida after arriving from Grinaker Rangers, recently opened up about his playing days in a special feature aired by SuperSport TV ahead of the Soweto Derby. Speaking to presenter Phumlani Msibi, the Chiefs icon shed light on why, despite his knack for finding the net, he was always passed over when it came to spot-kicks.

“I wasn’t allowed to take penalties because I was way down the pecking order,” McGregor admitted. “We had too many good players who were designated to take them. I only took spot-kicks during penalty shootouts. That was the only time I was entrusted with a penalty.”

McGregor’s honesty surprised many fans who remember his consistency and ability to score under pressure. However, his rare penalty moments were not without drama. Recalling a memorable incident during the South Africa vs All-Stars match in 1992, he shared a humorous exchange with former England and Kaizer Chiefs goalkeeper Gary Bailey.

“The week before, we were training at Chiefs, and Gary was having all of us practice penalties, though I didn’t realise it at the time,” McGregor said. “When we entered the penalty shootout in that game, Gary approached me just before I was about to take my kick and said: ‘Shane, I know where you’re going to place your penalty’.”

Caught off guard, McGregor panicked and opted to change his usual placement.

“At that moment, I changed my mind and aimed for the top corner. They’re still searching for that ball somewhere outside the stadium!” he laughed.

While he might not have been a regular from the spot, McGregor’s contributions to Kaizer Chiefs remain monumental. His goals, work ethic, and chemistry with teammates like Madida helped define a golden generation for the club — one that dominated domestic football and captured the hearts of millions.

In the history of the Soweto giants, McGregor’s story serves as a reminder that greatness isn’t always about the spotlight roles. Sometimes, it’s about playing your part — even if it means leaving the penalties to someone else.